European whistleblowers call for a better directive
In an open letter to the European Council, Commission and Parliament, five well-known European whistleblowers speak out for changing the directive and removing barriers for safe reporting. This letter is published as the negotiations between the European institutions are entering the final stretch.
The European Council, Commission and Parliament have started the trilogue phase since the end of January and one main point of discord remains: what procedure whistleblowers should follow to be granted protection against retaliation? The draft directive indicates three reporting channels: internal within the company, external to an authority, and public including through the press.
In the letter, the five whistleblowers are emphasizing that it was only by taking their concerns outside the organisations where they were working that they were able to be heard. The European Federation of Journalists (EFJ) shared the worry at several occasions and joined them in asking for strengthening protection for reporting more widely to the public.
For the attention of:
The Romanian Presidency
Vice President Timmermans and Commissioner Jourová
Virginie Rozière MEP
25th February 2019,
We are writing to you now to urge you to pass a European law to protect whistleblowers that will make a real difference. We each raised serious concerns that we came across at work and it was only by taking our concerns outside the organisations where we worked that we were able to ensure that the wrongdoing was taken seriously in our countries and in Europe. Our efforts have helped EU and national policy makers address serious problems and make new laws in the best interests of all Europeans. Protecting whistleblowers strengthens European democracy.
But the costs to us for acting as we did were very high. We lost our jobs, were prosecuted, had our professional and personal credibility attacked, and suffered the huge financial and psychological strain of having to fight for survival against powers far greater than ours alone. We persisted beyond what most people would be willing to endure to ensure the public interest was protected. The people of Europe deserve better.
The Directive must live up to its promise of strengthening fundamental rights by “safeguarding freedom of expression, the public’s right to know and media freedom” – all issues that urgently need reinforcing in Europe today. You can help make this happen.
If the current EU Council position is adopted, future whistleblowers in Europe will suffer as much – if not more – than we did. Even more worrying is that people will choose to stay silent in the face of wrongdoing that harms us all.
Therefore, we call on you to ensure an EU directive to protect whistleblowers removes any barriers to safely report directly to competent authorities, protects those who speak up through their regular management structure and not just through employer prescribed systems, and significantly strengthens protections for reporting more widely to the public.
Antoine Deltour (multinational tax avoidance schemes in Luxembourg, LuxLeaks)
Ana Garrido Ramos (corrupt practices in municipal Town Hall, leading to Gürtel scandal, Spain)
Andrea Franzoso (high value fraud committed by President of company, Italy)
Brigitte Heinisch (chronic understaffing causing severe ill-treatment of elderly people in care, Germany)
Raphaël Halet (multinational tax avoidance schemes in Luxembourg, LuxLeaks)
Photo credit. Antoine Deltour (Photo: Eurocadres), Ana Garrido Ramos (Photo: Transparency International) , Brigitte Heinisch (Photo: https://www.changeofdirection.eu/campaign-central/germany), Andrea Franzoso (Photo: Riparte Il Futuro https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=77&v=MQrW2OLEkaI) , Raphaël Halet (Photo: https://helpraph.wordpress.com/visuels/)