Police violence in France: our open letter to the Minister of the Interior
The European Federation of Journalists (EFJ) joined the International Federation of Journalists (IFJ) and our affiliates in France (SNJ, SNJ-CGT, CFDT-Journalistes, and SGJ-FO) to send an open letter this Thursday, November 12, to the French Minister of the Interior Laurent Nunez during a meeting he initiated with all journalists’ trade union organizations as well as Reporters Without Borders, the Commission for the Identity Card of Professional Journalists, and the Alliance of General Information Press (APIG, an employers’ organization).
During this meeting, the minister was very attentive. He has already responded to our first request: a firm reminder of the instructions in the National Order Maintenance Plan (SNMO) concerning journalists was to be given in the evening to the prefects and reminded them the next day by video.
He promised that changes would be visible at upcoming demonstrations. We are waiting to see.
Our open letter:
Laurent Nunez, call your law enforcement to order!
Since the beginning of autumn, following the actions of high school students, many citizens have been mobilized against the high cost of living and for education. With a climax on October 17, these demonstrations were marked by systematic and disproportionate use of force by law enforcement, as well as by the frequent refusal to authorize demonstrations.
These choices can only lead to more violent behavior, whether from law enforcement or some protesters, of which many journalists are victims across the country.
About thirty journalists assaulted
According to statistics compiled by professional organizations, several dozen colleagues have been victims of this violence, whether physical or psychological violence, sometimes with serious harm to their integrity, verbal violence, intimidation, or obstruction of the free exercise of their profession. Several of them have already filed complaints.
This violence is unacceptable
As AFP reminds us, following injuries inflicted on several of its journalists in Paris, Lyon, and Lille, “the ability for journalists to observe, photograph, and film law enforcement operations is an essential aspect of their information mission.” This freedom is also the freedom of citizens to be able to be informed.
The European platform Media Freedom Rapide Response (MFRR) already lists 27 obstacles to journalists in Paris, Lyon, Toulouse, Bordeaux, Montpellier, and the list is not exhaustive. These alerts will be posted on the Council of Europe’s platform for journalist safety, and the government will be required to respond.
Laurent Nunez, we urge you to:
- firmly remind law enforcement that their role should be to protect journalists at demonstrations, not to hinder their work or, worse, to commit violence against them;
- to stop insults, especially when presenting a press card, and to expressly prohibit the seizure of them;
- order law enforcement to stop seizing images, audio recordings (etc.), phones, or any other materials and tools used by journalists. This is a direct attack on the secrecy of sources, whose protection is guaranteed by law.
As trade unions representing journalists, we no longer want our colleagues, who are perfectly identifiable, to be jostled, clubbed, or deliberately targeted by blows or water cannons.
We demand that the right to identify police officers be effective, and not hindered by masked or even absent RIOs, or by the abuse of wearing balaclavas. It is a matter of democracy.
We want the free movement of journalists within security devices to be guaranteed and for them to no longer be “confused” with protesters or accused of obstructing law enforcement during warnings to end – or even start – demonstrations.
All these principles are included in your National Law Enforcement Plan (SNMO). The least we can do would be to enforce them. In its chapter dedicated to journalists (paragraph 2.2), it explicitly states: “The physical security of journalists must be guaranteed.”
It’s up to you to enforce it!








